Tant d’enfants pour une vierge.

On November 4, 1940, Marshal Petain visited the Ingres Museum in Montauban, where Louvre treasures were temporarily sheltered away from German bombings. Before Murillo's The Immaculate Conception of the Venerables, he commented sarcastically: "Tant d'enfants pour une Vierge!" ("So many children for a Virgin!"). Shortly after, the work would leave France for Francoist Spain, at the beginning of an episode in which art became a diplomatic tool at the service of propaganda and national identity.

The artistic exchange between Spain and France in 1940, which returned Murillo's Immaculate Conception to Spain in exchange for works such as a Velazquez and a portrait by El Greco, was much more than a gesture of cultural diplomacy. Set at the beginning of the Second World War and led by two authoritarian regimes, the episode reveals how art served the construction of historical memory and the national identity of Francoism.

The work already possessed a consolidated symbolic value. At the auction of Marshal Soult's collection in the mid nineteenth century, it reached the highest price paid for a painting up to that time and was acquired by the Louvre. That figure confirmed Murillo as one of the most highly valued Spanish painters on the international market between 1850 and 1870, when he was considered the perfect painter.

Beyond aesthetics, the Immaculate Conception embodied an image of power that attracted bidders such as Isabella II, Tsar Nicholas I, or the National Gallery in London. That same symbolic weight led Franco to claim it decades later: for the regime, the work, with its whiteness and purity, was a central piece of National Catholic propaganda. The agreement with Petain returned the Immaculate Conception to Spain, along with pieces such as the Lady of Elche and fragments of the Treasure of Guarrazar, in exchange for prominent works for France.

The negotiation was led by the Marquis of Lozoya, General Director of Fine Arts, with Luis Perez Bueno, Marcelino Macarron, and the painter Jose Maria Sert as unofficial representatives. The argument supporting the Spanish interest left no room for doubt: it was "the most perfect image of the patron saint of Spain", a claim laden with nostalgia for a past greatness and a notion of racial and cultural identity. Linked since its installation in 1665 to the celebrations in front of Santa Maria la Blanca, the work thus became the ultimate symbol of national power and purity. French critics, for their part, justified the transfer by describing Murillo as a "decadent" and old fashioned artist.

In fact, at the beginning of the twentieth century, Murillo had already lost the favor of the avant garde, who preferred a more conceptual Velazquez. Even Zurbaran, eclipsed by Murillo in life, eventually surpassed him in the interest of modern artists. The French press took advantage of this critical decline to justify the exchange, while in Spain it was celebrated as a diplomatic victory over France.

Finally, installed in the Prado Museum, The Immaculate Conception was consolidated as a national icon of exalted Catholicism: a symbol of purity and power.